Manchester United 4 - 3 Hull City

Champions hang on against battling Hull

Updated: November 1, 2008, 5:16 PM UK

They may not have won, or even claimed a point, but Hull City's triumphant march on the Premier League won fresh admirers after they finally gave way in a pulsating 4-3 defeat at Manchester United.

• Ferguson feels frustration

At 4-1 up just before the hour mark, the Premier League and European champions should have cruised home.

Instead, they reached the final whistle severely rattled as Bernard Mendy and Geovanni breathed new life into the contest and forced Sir Alex Ferguson's men to cling on for maximum points, with Cristiano Ronaldo netting a double.

As they had already won at Newcastle, Tottenham and, more pertinently, Arsenal this season, Hull had every reason to travel across the M62 to Old Trafford for a league game for the first time since 1975 nursing at least hope.

They refused to buckle even after Ronaldo had given United a third minute lead, although the slack marking that allowed Ronaldo to exchange passes with Dimitar Berbatov before seeing his shot cannon in off Boaz Myhill's left-hand post would eventually return to haunt them.

With Geovanni floating around behind Cousin and Marlon King, the Tigers were not easy to contain.

Nemanja Vidic found it particularly difficult and was fortunate not to be booked, if not for the severity of his fouls, then the regularity with which they took place.

Midway through the half, the normally dependable Serb had a tug at King's shirt, presenting Andy Dawson with the opportunity to curl a dangerous free-kick into the heart of United's penalty area.

Cousin rose above a crowd of bodies, glanced his header beyond Edwin van der Sar and Hull's army of fans dared to dream.

Had Phil Brown's men held United for any length of time, they might have ended up with something, although their naive defending would always lead to trouble at this level.

As it was, just six minutes elapsed before Vidic and Wayne Rooney combined to set up a lightning counter-attack in which Berbatov took the ball on before feeding Michael Carrick to his left.

Just as Ronaldo was given too much space earlier, so the Hull defence backed off Carrick. The England midfielder reached the edge of the area before Paul McShane closed in. By then it was too late.

Carrick may have been making his first start for seven weeks but a bit of ring-rust was not going to stop him hitting the same post as Ronaldo had done, with exactly the same result.

Ferguson expressed his displeasure at Goodison Park last weekend and against West Ham on Wednesday at the lack of a cutting edge from his team, so they were not likely to ease up a third time.

Myhill beat away a Ronaldo effort, then Rooney had a goal correctly disallowed for a marginal offside decision before Nani drifted a corner to the near post two minutes before the interval which Ronaldo powered home.

Although the next goal would have brought Hull back into it, Brown knew damage limitation was the order of the day as the teams re-emerged.

For 15 minutes, United peppered the Hull goal, with Ronaldo and Berbatov going close. They scored once, when Vidic turned home Rooney's corner.

But Ferguson wanted more and introduced Carlos Tevez for Nani. It meant United had £90million-worth of attacking talent on the pitch, plus Ronaldo, whose goal tally had shot up to seven.

Amazingly though, Hull were the ones who scored as substitute Mendy outjumped Patrice Evra, then beat Van der Sar with a lob which had crossed the line before Vidic hooked it out.

Still Ferguson was not deterred and with Ryan Giggs on as well, United were playing fantasy football as Rooney, Tevez and Berbatov all threatened.

The commitment to attack left them vulnerable at the back and as Hull shared the same instinct, it was no surprise Mendy found himself in the United box once more. Ferdinand hauled him back. Geovanni converted the penalty and a capacity crowd were treated to a pulsating last eight minutes in which tempers became as short as the entertainment value had been long.

Rooney was among those booked as his fuse threatened to burn out completely. It lasted just long enough, as did United's slender lead.

Ferguson feels frustration

After the match Sir Alex Ferguson admitted Manchester United nearly ended up embarrassed.

"I feel a bit low," said the United boss.

"We should have won by 10 or 11 and we ended up scrambling for a victory. We might have been embarrassed at the end.

"Cristiano Ronaldo could have had four or five on his own and I don't know how many chances Dimitar Berbatov created.

"I suppose the only thing to take out of it, apart from the win, is the fact we are creating so many opportunities for ourselves."

Ferguson was fuming at the performance of referee Mike Dean, who he felt was in danger of losing control in the fractious final stages, with Wayne Rooney at particular risk as tempers began to fray.

But it was Dean's decision not to dismiss an already-booked Michael Turner for a foul on Michael Carrick midway through the second-half that really angered the United boss.

"It should have been at least a yellow card, in which case the player would have been sent off," said Ferguson. "It made a difference."

Ferguson was also upset at the penalty award for Rio Ferdinand's tug on Mendy's shirt that set up the pulsating finish.

"It was very soft," said the Scot. "Their lad was going away from goal."

Ferguson's assessment is debatable and should not be allowed to detract from Hull's magnificent effort.

Ronaldo's two first-half efforts took his tally to seven for the season and 99 for United overall.

Michael Carrick immediately replied after Daniel Cousin had levelled Ronaldo's opening effort and once Vidic extended the lead, a landslide seemed likely.

Instead, Hull hit back, becoming the first visiting side since Chelsea in 2005 to score three times at Old Trafford.

"It's mixed emotions," reflected Hull boss Phil Brown.

"We can take a lot of pride from the game but nothing else. That is disappointing when you consider we scored three times.

"I was not happy at half-time but we got in their faces a lot more in the second half and really battled hard.

"In some ways, I have more belief in this team than they have in themselves.

"But I feel we have proved we are capable of competing at this level. Hopefully it continues for a long time yet."