| Toronto FC 2009 Picks |
| NAME | POS | COLLEGE/OTHER | RD | PICK (OVR) | HT | WT |
| Sam Cronin | M | Wake Forest University | 1 | 1st (2nd) | 5-10 |
165 |
| Comment: 2008 Hermann Trophy finalist, career totals of 17 goals and 19 assists at Wake. |
| O'brian White | F | University of Connecticut | 1 | 1st (4th) | 6-1 |
175 |
| Comment: 2007 Hermann Trophy winner saw his final season at UConn disrupted by injury. Still recovering from an ACL injury. |
| Stefan Frei* | GK | University of California | 1 | 1st (13th) | 6-3 |
195 |
| Comment: Two-time All-American for California-Berkeley. Native of Switzerland who was named MLS combine MVP. |
| Mike Grella | F | Duke University | 3 | 3rd (34th) | 5-10 |
170 |
| Kyle Hall | F | Syracuse | 3 | 3rd (39th) | 5-8 |
155 |
H