| PICK | NAME, POSITION | DRAFTED FROM | TEAM | HT |
WT |
| 31st | Jared Karkas, D | Azusa Pacific | Seattle Sounders FC | 6-1 |
0 |
| 32nd | Quincy Amarikwa, F | University of California - Davis | San Jose Earthquakes | 5-9 |
160 |
| 33rd | Josh Boateng, F | Liberty University | Los Angeles Galaxy | 5-9 |
160 |
| 34th | Mike Grella, F | Duke University | Toronto FC | 5-10 |
170 |
| 35th | Kyle Christensen, F | University of Denver | Chivas USA (From Colorado) | 6-1 |
187 |
| 36th | Brandon Barklage, F/M | Saint Louis University | DC United | 5-11 |
165 |
| 37th | Steward Ceus, GK | University of Albany | Colorado Rapids | 6-6 |
205 |
| 38th | Chris Salvaggione, F | UNC Charlotte | New England Revolution (From Kansas City) | 5-11 |
170 |
| 39th | Kyle Hall, F | Syracuse | Toronto FC (From Dallas, Chivas) | 5-8 |
155 |
| 40th | Darrius Barnes, D | Duke University | New England Revolution | 6-1 |
175 |
| 41st | Daniel Cruz*, M | University of Nevada Las Vegas | Houston Dynamo | 5-8 |
170 |
| 42nd | Neal Kitson, GK | St John's University | Kansas City Wizards (From Real Salt Lake) | 6-1 |
180 |
| 43rd | David Sias, D | University of Cal-Irvine | Chicago Fire | 6-1 |
175 |
| 44th | Nick Zimmerman, M | James Madison University | New York Red Bulls | 6-0 |
184 |
| 45th | Alex Grendi, F/M | University of Pennsylvania | Columbus Crew | 5-11 |
0 |
H